I guess in that way I’m lucky

Occasionally I’ll sit down and brainstorm blog post ideas, and while brainstorming posts about reviews, my mind-mapping came up with a post about one-star reviews.

I don’t have any of those. I guess in that way I’m lucky. I don’t have enough reviews to have someone pick up one of my books and complain that it was realistic, or erotica, or whatever. Which, when you think about it, is its own kind of failure. A one-star review means someone found you. It means your book climbed far enough up some algorithm or recommendation list that a stranger with no connection to you clicked “buy,” read the thing, hated it, and cared enough to come back and say so in public.

The writers I envy aren’t the ones with perfect five-star averages. Those averages usually mean twelve reviews, nine of them from people who know the author’s name in real life. The writers I envy have four hundred reviews and a solid chunk of one- and two-star ragers, because that spread means actual sales to actual strangers. The hate is a byproduct of volume. You cannot have one without the other.

So I’ve started to think of the one-star review as a milestone instead of a wound. Somewhere out there is my first furious reader. They haven’t found me yet. Maybe they’re browsing a category page right now and scrolling right past my cover. Maybe they’re three years away. But when they arrive, and they will, they’ll do it with feeling. They’ll leave a review titled something like “Not what I expected” or “Save your money,” and they’ll detail exactly how the book offended their sensibilities, and I will read it probably more than once.

And I’ll know I made it. Not big. Not famous. Just big enough that a person who owes me nothing decided I was worth the energy of a complaint. That’s the dream. A terrible, specific, deeply satisfying dream.

Until then I’ll keep writing, keep publishing, and keep checking a review page that stays politely, frustratingly empty. The silence isn’t peace. It’s a waiting room. I just hope my first hater brings their A-game.